Is Comprehensive Auto Insurance Worth It? A Comprehensive Guide

Having comprehensive and collision coverage can provide vital additional protection, especially if you're leasing or financing your car or if you're driving a high-value vehicle. You may be wondering if it's worth it to invest in comprehensive auto insurance. The answer depends on the value of your car, the cost of insurance, and your deductible. Comprehensive coverage can be a worthwhile investment if you have a new car and want to help protect your finances in case of theft or damage.

Consider whether you can afford expensive repairs to your car or replace it. Otherwise, comprehensive coverage may be worth paying for. Since ACV is the maximum amount a comprehensive auto insurance policy will pay, cars that are worth less are cheaper to insure. Comprehensive insurance coverage limits are determined based on the actual cash value of the vehicle, so the more a car is worth, the more the insurer will pay in the event of a claim. A good way to find out if comprehensive coverage is worth it is to compare the value of your car with the cost of insurance and your deductible.

Once your collision and comprehensive bill for approximately five years approaches the potential insurance payment, it probably isn't worth keeping the additional coverage. Likewise, even if your comprehensive premium is 15% of the value of your car, for example, comprehensive insurance could be worthwhile if you're dependent on the car and can't afford to replace it yourself. Comprehensive insurance could be a worthwhile investment, especially if you have a new car with a high market value and want to protect your finances in the event of vandalism, natural disaster, theft, or contact with an animal. That's because your maximum payment, which is the value of the car minus the amount of the deductible, is likely to be extremely low and, over time, not worth the cost of insurance. An expensive vehicle, such as a Mercedes, can be worth the cost of the collision and comprehensive coverage for several years longer than a Nissan Sentra. It may also be worth taking out comprehensive insurance if the policyholder cannot afford to replace the vehicle without comprehensive coverage, or if the car is being driven or parked in a particularly risky area.

Include your deductible as well, and the potential insurance payment may not be worth the price of coverage. Paying for all-risk and collision coverage, the coverages that many people refer to when they say that full coverage may not be worth it if the value of the car is minimal and your policy includes a high deductible. In that case, it's definitely worth taking out comprehensive insurance, as not meeting the requirements of the lender or landlord could result in expensive insurance and even in the recovery of the property. Now, the standard rule is that it's worth buying both comprehensive and collision coverage if the combined premium is less than 10% of the car's value, minus the deductible. This means that if you have an expensive vehicle with a low deductible and low premiums for both coverages combined, then it's probably worth investing in comprehensive auto insurance. Ultimately, whether or not comprehensive auto insurance is worth it depends on your individual circumstances.

Consider how much money you would have to pay out-of-pocket in case of an accident or theft before deciding whether or not to invest in this type of coverage.

Carl Somilleda
Carl Somilleda

General beer ninja. Hardcore social media guru. Devoted beer guru. Hardcore beer geek. Hipster-friendly web aficionado.